From 15c97cb29a4210e9400cc05fa292cd185a811e9b Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Morpheus Date: Thu, 27 Aug 2026 05:02:56 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Review overnight flux2klein smoke --- benchmarks/flux2klein/README.md | 2 +- benchmarks/flux2klein/overnight-state.json | 4 +-- optimized/notes/flux2klein.md | 2 +- .../notes/reviews/2026-08-27-daily-review.md | 27 +++++++++++++++++++ 4 files changed, 31 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-) create mode 100644 optimized/notes/reviews/2026-08-27-daily-review.md diff --git a/benchmarks/flux2klein/README.md b/benchmarks/flux2klein/README.md index 6b1874f..3ee16c9 100644 --- a/benchmarks/flux2klein/README.md +++ b/benchmarks/flux2klein/README.md @@ -39,7 +39,7 @@ Do not call a workflow fully optimal from one benchmark image. Use these batches ## Latest review -- 2026-08-27 overnight single-image smoke: clean full-body studio restage with preserved blonde identity, gold corset, black thigh-high boots, and a clean white seamless background. Keep `runs/2026-08-27T02-08-31-134Z-single-smoke/` as the current benchmark winner for now, but queue one more smoke test before any broader promotion. +- 2026-08-27 overnight single-image smoke, reviewed: clean full-body studio restage with preserved blonde identity, gold corset, black thigh-high boots, and a clean white seamless background. Keep `runs/2026-08-27T02-08-31-134Z-single-smoke/` as the current benchmark winner for now, but queue one more smoke test before any broader promotion. - 2026-08-23 overnight single-image smoke: clean full-body white-background restage with strong identity retention, a tidy silhouette, and no obvious background clutter. Keep `runs/2026-08-23T02-05-24-860Z-single-smoke/` as the current benchmark winner, but queue one more smoke test before any broader promotion. - 2026-08-21 overnight single-image smoke: clean full-body studio restage on a pure white background, with good identity retention and a tidy silhouette. Treat it as the current benchmark winner for now, but keep one more smoke test queued before any stronger promotion. - 2026-08-22 overnight single-image smoke: another clean white-background restage with strong identity retention, a tidy full-body silhouette, and no obvious background clutter. It was the prior winner before the 2026-08-23 run. diff --git a/benchmarks/flux2klein/overnight-state.json b/benchmarks/flux2klein/overnight-state.json index becca99..0daf509 100644 --- a/benchmarks/flux2klein/overnight-state.json +++ b/benchmarks/flux2klein/overnight-state.json @@ -24,8 +24,8 @@ } } ], - "reviewPending": true, - "verdict": null, + "reviewPending": false, + "verdict": "Reviewed: keep current winner; identity and background are clean, but one more smoke test is still warranted before broader promotion.", "date": "2026-08-27T02:09:46.801Z", "optimizedPaths": [ "optimized/image-edit/flux2klein-9b-fp8-edit-master", diff --git a/optimized/notes/flux2klein.md b/optimized/notes/flux2klein.md index 3f0ccf8..6a6a0c7 100644 --- a/optimized/notes/flux2klein.md +++ b/optimized/notes/flux2klein.md @@ -51,7 +51,7 @@ - Treat the `geceff` multi-reference pack as a donor for future reference-heavy variants, not as the first default promotion. - The 2026-08-22 overnight `image-edit-9b-distilled` smoke stayed clean enough to keep the current `flux2klein-9b-fp8-edit-master` lane as the benchmark winner for now: strong identity retention, a tidy full-body silhouette, and a clean white background. Keep one more smoke test queued before any broader claim of stability. - The 2026-08-23 overnight `image-edit-9b-distilled` smoke is still clean enough to keep `flux2klein-9b-fp8-edit-master` as the benchmark winner: identity stayed locked, the body read stayed clean, and the white background remained uncluttered. Queue another smoke test before any stronger promotion. -- The 2026-08-27 overnight `image-edit-9b-distilled` smoke also stayed clean enough to keep `flux2klein-9b-fp8-edit-master` as the benchmark winner for now: identity retention is still strong, the silhouette is tidy, and the white background stayed uncluttered. Queue one more smoke test before any broader promotion. +- The 2026-08-27 overnight `image-edit-9b-distilled` smoke held up on review and is still clean enough to keep `flux2klein-9b-fp8-edit-master` as the benchmark winner for now: identity retention is still strong, the silhouette is tidy, and the white background stayed uncluttered. Queue one more smoke test before any broader promotion. ## What needs Monday proof diff --git a/optimized/notes/reviews/2026-08-27-daily-review.md b/optimized/notes/reviews/2026-08-27-daily-review.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d4c973f --- /dev/null +++ b/optimized/notes/reviews/2026-08-27-daily-review.md @@ -0,0 +1,27 @@ +# 2026-08-27 Daily Review + +## Scope + +Reviewed the overnight `flux2klein` single-image smoke test recorded in `benchmarks/flux2klein/overnight-state.json`. + +## Tests found + +- One successful overnight smoke test in `runs/2026-08-27T02-08-31-134Z-single-smoke/`. +- Workflow: `models/flux2klein/image-edit-9b-distilled/workflow.json` +- Output: `benchmarks/flux2klein/runs/2026-08-27T02-08-31-134Z-single-smoke/cases/case01/01-flux2klein-overnight-smoke_00002_.png` + +## Best output + +- Clean full-body studio restage on a pure white seamless background. +- Identity retention is strong enough to keep the current winner in place for now. +- The gold corset and black thigh-high boots stayed readable and the silhouette stayed tidy. +- No obvious background clutter or compositional noise. + +## Verdict + +Keep `runs/2026-08-27T02-08-31-134Z-single-smoke/` as the current benchmark winner, but do not treat it as fully settled from one image. + +## Follow-up + +- Queue one more smoke test on a later night. +- Use the next test to confirm the identity lock and background cleanliness hold up across another sample.