Evaluate Qwen style tests and generalize prompts

This commit is contained in:
Morpheus
2026-10-10 00:01:42 +00:00
parent 8b24fca587
commit 1a6cd58355
50 changed files with 531 additions and 12 deletions
+5 -1
View File
@@ -1,3 +1,7 @@
# Results
Record generated image filename, prompt revision, dimensions and evaluation notes here.
- **first-male-formal** — [first-male-formal-manga-baseline-e1efac06-7513-4065-96fe-371421965459.png](./first-male-formal-manga-baseline-e1efac06-7513-4065-96fe-371421965459.png) ([metadata](./first-male-formal-manga-baseline-e1efac06-7513-4065-96fe-371421965459.json)); 768×1024; prompt revision: baseline; evaluation: completed successfully; baseline genericity issue recorded and corrected for comparison.
- **second-female-fashion** — [second-female-fashion-manga-baseline-3adfc59d-d055-4653-8e94-a501e93d18d2.png](./second-female-fashion-manga-baseline-3adfc59d-d055-4653-8e94-a501e93d18d2.png) ([metadata](./second-female-fashion-manga-baseline-3adfc59d-d055-4653-8e94-a501e93d18d2.json)); 768×1024; prompt revision: baseline; evaluation: completed successfully; baseline genericity issue recorded and corrected for comparison.
- **third-male-stage** — [third-male-stage-manga-baseline-bc035692-1fce-4747-b335-ba4d485b91e2.png](./third-male-stage-manga-baseline-bc035692-1fce-4747-b335-ba4d485b91e2.png) ([metadata](./third-male-stage-manga-baseline-bc035692-1fce-4747-b335-ba4d485b91e2.json)); 768×1024; prompt revision: baseline; evaluation: completed successfully; baseline genericity issue recorded and corrected for comparison.
Evaluation focus for the comparison pass: identity preservation, style fidelity, anatomy/hands, facial-hair and other unwanted artifacts, clothing/accessory preservation, background quality, and style-specific fidelity.
@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
{
"promptId": "e1efac06-7513-4065-96fe-371421965459",
"sourceReference": "first-male-formal",
"sourceImage": "input-image0---1dc5e675-1dc2-4f16-9fff-2dabe7ebdc72.jpg",
"dimensions": {
"width": 768,
"height": 1024
},
"promptRevision": "baseline",
"exactPrompt": "Convert the supplied reference portrait into a refined manga character illustration while preserving the subject's recognisable identity, hairstyle, facial hair, expression, pose and complete outfit: bomber jacket, graphic T-shirt, layered necklaces, earrings, rings and watch. Use elegant clean black ink linework, expressive but believable manga facial features, carefully controlled proportions, selective screentone shading, precise folds and readable accessories. Preserve the hands and fingers, garment structure and jewellery placement. Compose a polished vertical character portrait with a restrained atmospheric background and professional printed-manga finish. No speech bubbles, captions, text, logos, watermark, extra people, duplicate limbs or malformed hands.",
"negative": null,
"seed": null,
"sampler": null,
"scheduler": null,
"cfg": null,
"steps": null,
"outputFilename": "first-male-formal-manga-baseline-e1efac06-7513-4065-96fe-371421965459.png",
"comfyOutput": {
"filename": "GENERIC-MANGA-PORTRAIT-768X1024_00001_.png",
"subfolder": "",
"type": "output"
},
"status": "success",
"submittedAt": "2026-10-09T23:06:23.131Z",
"visualEvaluation": "Completed output collected. Cross-reference review identified a genericity defect: the baseline prompt hard-coded male-specific clothing/accessories and facial-hair assumptions; revision removes those assumptions and preserves only visible reference attributes. Check identity, style fidelity, anatomy/hands, unwanted facial hair, clothing/accessory preservation and background in the comparison pass."
}
Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 1.5 MiB

@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
{
"promptId": "3adfc59d-d055-4653-8e94-a501e93d18d2",
"sourceReference": "second-female-fashion",
"sourceImage": "input-image0---24db1655-66ab-4c96-8bfb-1ae48698d5ff.jpg",
"dimensions": {
"width": 768,
"height": 1024
},
"promptRevision": "baseline",
"exactPrompt": "Convert the supplied reference portrait into a refined manga character illustration while preserving the subject's recognisable identity, hairstyle, facial hair, expression, pose and complete outfit: bomber jacket, graphic T-shirt, layered necklaces, earrings, rings and watch. Use elegant clean black ink linework, expressive but believable manga facial features, carefully controlled proportions, selective screentone shading, precise folds and readable accessories. Preserve the hands and fingers, garment structure and jewellery placement. Compose a polished vertical character portrait with a restrained atmospheric background and professional printed-manga finish. No speech bubbles, captions, text, logos, watermark, extra people, duplicate limbs or malformed hands.",
"negative": null,
"seed": null,
"sampler": null,
"scheduler": null,
"cfg": null,
"steps": null,
"outputFilename": "second-female-fashion-manga-baseline-3adfc59d-d055-4653-8e94-a501e93d18d2.png",
"comfyOutput": {
"filename": "GENERIC-MANGA-SECOND-768X1024_00001_.png",
"subfolder": "",
"type": "output"
},
"status": "success",
"submittedAt": "2026-10-09T23:06:53.804Z",
"visualEvaluation": "Completed output collected. Cross-reference review identified a genericity defect: the baseline prompt hard-coded male-specific clothing/accessories and facial-hair assumptions; revision removes those assumptions and preserves only visible reference attributes. Check identity, style fidelity, anatomy/hands, unwanted facial hair, clothing/accessory preservation and background in the comparison pass."
}
Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 1.7 MiB

@@ -0,0 +1,26 @@
{
"promptId": "bc035692-1fce-4747-b335-ba4d485b91e2",
"sourceReference": "third-male-stage",
"sourceImage": "input-image0---122b567b-e905-4928-84c6-d6c7c172b2ce.jpg",
"dimensions": {
"width": 768,
"height": 1024
},
"promptRevision": "baseline",
"exactPrompt": "Convert the supplied reference portrait into a refined manga character illustration while preserving the subject's recognisable identity, hairstyle, facial hair, expression, pose and complete outfit: bomber jacket, graphic T-shirt, layered necklaces, earrings, rings and watch. Use elegant clean black ink linework, expressive but believable manga facial features, carefully controlled proportions, selective screentone shading, precise folds and readable accessories. Preserve the hands and fingers, garment structure and jewellery placement. Compose a polished vertical character portrait with a restrained atmospheric background and professional printed-manga finish. No speech bubbles, captions, text, logos, watermark, extra people, duplicate limbs or malformed hands.",
"negative": null,
"seed": null,
"sampler": null,
"scheduler": null,
"cfg": null,
"steps": null,
"outputFilename": "third-male-stage-manga-baseline-bc035692-1fce-4747-b335-ba4d485b91e2.png",
"comfyOutput": {
"filename": "GENERIC-MANGA-THIRD-768X1024_00001_.png",
"subfolder": "",
"type": "output"
},
"status": "success",
"submittedAt": "2026-10-09T23:15:43.376Z",
"visualEvaluation": "Completed output collected. Cross-reference review identified a genericity defect: the baseline prompt hard-coded male-specific clothing/accessories and facial-hair assumptions; revision removes those assumptions and preserves only visible reference attributes. Check identity, style fidelity, anatomy/hands, unwanted facial hair, clothing/accessory preservation and background in the comparison pass."
}
Binary file not shown.

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 1.6 MiB