Refresh daily workflow review notes

This commit is contained in:
Morpheus
2026-08-20 20:07:50 +00:00
parent a84c26a5f5
commit 69f3c0f9c3
7 changed files with 67 additions and 1 deletions
+1
View File
@@ -6,5 +6,6 @@ Home for maintained category masters focused on image-to-video generation.
- `ltx23-3070-simple-master` - `ltx23-3070-simple-master`
- `minimax-h3-3070-single-10s-1152x640-r2v-master` - `minimax-h3-3070-single-10s-1152x640-r2v-master`
- `minimax-h3-best-current-r2v-master-480p-3x10s`
- `minimax-h3-contex-loop-3070-compact-30s` - `minimax-h3-contex-loop-3070-compact-30s`
- `minimax-h3-contex-loop-3070-compact-prepend-480p-3x10s` - `minimax-h3-contex-loop-3070-compact-prepend-480p-3x10s`
@@ -16,10 +16,17 @@ subject-definition prompts for continuity across the chain.
- `workflow.json` - `workflow.json`
## This pass
- Tightened the clip prompts so `<Picture 1>` carries the master scene and `<Picture 2>` carries the primary full-body identity, matching the current Ref2VA prompt hierarchy.
- Kept the `clip_by_clip` validation flow and the `480p` / `3 x 10s` budget intact.
## Built from ## Built from
- `optimized/image-to-video/minimax-h3-extender-3070-r2v-480p-clip-by-clip/` - `optimized/image-to-video/minimax-h3-extender-3070-r2v-480p-clip-by-clip/`
- `models/minimax/minimax-h3-extender-ref2va/` - `models/minimax/minimax-h3-extender-ref2va/`
- `models/minimax/minimax-h3-int8-r2v-javano2608-23/`
- current MiniMax Ref2VA prompt guidance in `optimized/notes/minimax-h3-ref2va-prompt-guidelines.md`
- local lessons from: - local lessons from:
- `optimized/image-to-video/minimax-h3-contex-loop-3070-compact-prepend-480p-3x10s/` - `optimized/image-to-video/minimax-h3-contex-loop-3070-compact-prepend-480p-3x10s/`
- `optimized/image-to-video/minimax-h3-contex-loop-3070-compact-30s/` - `optimized/image-to-video/minimax-h3-contex-loop-3070-compact-30s/`
@@ -52,6 +59,9 @@ subject-definition prompts for continuity across the chain.
- the current compact `Contex Loop` masters still define the safe local budget, - the current compact `Contex Loop` masters still define the safe local budget,
and this workflow inherits that budget shape instead of pretending the source and this workflow inherits that budget shape instead of pretending the source
defaults are free defaults are free
- the newer same-day `javawock7618` `INT8 R2V` import is the strongest current
donor for tighter subject retention, so the maintained master now spells out
the scene/subject authority order more explicitly
- this is the cleanest current merge of: - this is the cleanest current merge of:
- better continuation workflow UX - better continuation workflow UX
- safer `3070 / 8 GB` assumptions - safer `3070 / 8 GB` assumptions
+6
View File
@@ -19,6 +19,9 @@
- Community Hugging Face workflow worth remembering: - Community Hugging Face workflow worth remembering:
- `models/flux2klein/community-gguf-kv-yarvixpa/` - `models/flux2klein/community-gguf-kv-yarvixpa/`
- Interesting because of KV-cache / GGUF optimization ideas, not because it is the default path - Interesting because of KV-cache / GGUF optimization ideas, not because it is the default path
- Community multi-reference donor worth watching:
- `models/flux2klein/geceff-flux2klein9b-multiref-3image/`
- Useful as a reference-control donor, but still too heavy and opinionated to replace the official `9B fp8` edit baseline by default
## Strong current heuristics ## Strong current heuristics
@@ -29,11 +32,13 @@
- `CFG=1` - `CFG=1`
- cleaner model/text-encoder pairing - cleaner model/text-encoder pairing
- avoiding broken loader substitutions - avoiding broken loader substitutions
- Keep the official `9B fp8` edit master as the default lane, then borrow from the multi-reference donor only when reference control is the real problem.
## Current weak areas ## Current weak areas
- We still do not have a clean, trusted, explicitly labeled `9B fp8 outpainting` community workflow import. - We still do not have a clean, trusted, explicitly labeled `9B fp8 outpainting` community workflow import.
- Some public workflow pages mention outpainting but do not expose a trustworthy raw workflow asset. - Some public workflow pages mention outpainting but do not expose a trustworthy raw workflow asset.
- The multi-reference donor is promising, but it is not a clean maintainable replacement for the current edit master.
## Best current optimization direction ## Best current optimization direction
@@ -42,6 +47,7 @@
- cleaner graph organization - cleaner graph organization
- low-step settings when they are clearly validated - low-step settings when they are clearly validated
- better reference/outpaint control if portable - better reference/outpaint control if portable
- Treat the `geceff` multi-reference pack as a donor for future reference-heavy variants, not as the first default promotion.
## What needs Monday proof ## What needs Monday proof
+4
View File
@@ -11,22 +11,26 @@
- `models/ltx/ltx23-t2v-simple-single-pass/` - `models/ltx/ltx23-t2v-simple-single-pass/`
- `models/ltx/ltx23-first-last-frame/` - `models/ltx/ltx23-first-last-frame/`
- `models/ltx/ltx23-character-sheet-best-face-id/` - `models/ltx/ltx23-character-sheet-best-face-id/`
- `models/ltx/ltx25-multiple-subject-reference/`
## Strong current heuristics ## Strong current heuristics
- Start with simple single-pass before trying larger consistency graphs. - Start with simple single-pass before trying larger consistency graphs.
- Prefer split-model and extracted-model routes when the source pack says they are easier locally. - Prefer split-model and extracted-model routes when the source pack says they are easier locally.
- Treat first-last-frame and character-sheet workflows as second-wave tests, not the baseline. - Treat first-last-frame and character-sheet workflows as second-wave tests, not the baseline.
- Keep the `LTX-2.5` multi-subject reference pack as the best current donor for heavier consistency work, but do not let it displace the simpler `LTX 2.3` master until we have proof on the `3070`.
## Current weak areas ## Current weak areas
- No real proof yet for what is genuinely practical on Chris's box. - No real proof yet for what is genuinely practical on Chris's box.
- Community packs bundle lots of helper nodes, which raises import fragility. - Community packs bundle lots of helper nodes, which raises import fragility.
- The newer `LTX-2.5` reference pack looks promising, but it is not yet a clean default candidate.
## Best current optimization direction ## Best current optimization direction
- Keep `optimized/image-to-video/ltx23-3070-simple-master/` as the first `LTX` default. - Keep `optimized/image-to-video/ltx23-3070-simple-master/` as the first `LTX` default.
- Only promote first-last-frame or character-sheet variants after the simple master proves viable. - Only promote first-last-frame or character-sheet variants after the simple master proves viable.
- Use the `LTX-2.5` multi-subject reference workflow as a future donor for reference-heavy jobs, not as the baseline.
## What needs Monday proof ## What needs Monday proof
+8
View File
@@ -12,17 +12,23 @@
- `models/minimax/minimax-h3-turbo-lora-community/` - `models/minimax/minimax-h3-turbo-lora-community/`
- `models/minimax/minimax-h3-int8-r2v-community/` - `models/minimax/minimax-h3-int8-r2v-community/`
- `models/minimax/minimax-h3-extender-ref2va/` - `models/minimax/minimax-h3-extender-ref2va/`
- `models/minimax/minimax-h3-int8-r2v-javano2608-23/`
- `models/minimax/minimax-h3-turbo-gguf-i2va/`
- `models/minimax/minimax-h3-seamless-chain-v2/`
## Strong current heuristics ## Strong current heuristics
- Prefer Turbo LoRA for the first `text-to-video` attempt. - Prefer Turbo LoRA for the first `text-to-video` attempt.
- Prefer INT8-based community workflows for `reference-to-video` exploration. - Prefer INT8-based community workflows for `reference-to-video` exploration.
- Keep attention and memory-efficiency helpers if they are already integrated and well documented. - Keep attention and memory-efficiency helpers if they are already integrated and well documented.
- Treat the same-day `javawock7618` `INT8 R2V` import as the strongest current donor for local continuity and identity retention, but not as proof that the graph is light enough for a `3070`.
- Keep the GGUF `I2VA` path as an audio-aware fallback, not the default lane.
## Current weak areas ## Current weak areas
- No proof yet that MiniMax is truly practical on Chris's box. - No proof yet that MiniMax is truly practical on Chris's box.
- Custom-node stack is more fragile than the current `flux2klein` path. - Custom-node stack is more fragile than the current `flux2klein` path.
- The full `seamless-chain` graph is interesting, but it is not a clean baseline for the first maintained master.
## Best current optimization direction ## Best current optimization direction
@@ -30,6 +36,7 @@
- Keep the INT8 reference-video workflow as the next donor for future low-VRAM optimization. - Keep the INT8 reference-video workflow as the next donor for future low-VRAM optimization.
- Keep `optimized/image-to-video/minimax-h3-extender-3070-r2v-480p-clip-by-clip/` as the first `MiniMax H3 Extender` path to compare against the compact `Contex Loop` masters. - Keep `optimized/image-to-video/minimax-h3-extender-3070-r2v-480p-clip-by-clip/` as the first `MiniMax H3 Extender` path to compare against the compact `Contex Loop` masters.
- Use `optimized/image-to-video/minimax-h3-best-current-r2v-master-480p-3x10s/` as the best-current default whenever Chris wants a `MiniMax H3` `reference-to-video` continuation workflow. - Use `optimized/image-to-video/minimax-h3-best-current-r2v-master-480p-3x10s/` as the best-current default whenever Chris wants a `MiniMax H3` `reference-to-video` continuation workflow.
- Use the new same-day `javawock7618` `INT8 R2V` import as the main donor for future `best-current-r2v` revisions if the current master needs another pass.
## Ref2VA prompt guidance ## Ref2VA prompt guidance
@@ -44,3 +51,4 @@
- whether the Turbo LoRA workflow is just technically possible or actually usable - whether the Turbo LoRA workflow is just technically possible or actually usable
- whether the source-recommended `8`-step path holds up in quality - whether the source-recommended `8`-step path holds up in quality
- whether MiniMax feels like a real challenger to `LTX` locally - whether MiniMax feels like a real challenger to `LTX` locally
- whether the same-day `INT8 R2V` donor stays practical on the `3070` once the helper stack is trimmed to the minimum
@@ -0,0 +1,27 @@
# 2026-08-20 Daily Review
## Scope
Reviewed the current MiniMax, Z-Image, LTX, and FLUX.2-klein source packs against the maintained optimized layer.
## Repo updates
- Updated `optimized/image-to-video/README.md` so the category index now lists the maintained `MiniMax H3` best-current R2V master.
- Refreshed `optimized/image-to-video/minimax-h3-best-current-r2v-master-480p-3x10s/README.md` with the current Ref2VA prompt hierarchy and the same-day MiniMax donor context.
## Notes updated
- `optimized/notes/minimax.md`
- `optimized/notes/ltx.md`
- `optimized/notes/zimage.md`
- `optimized/notes/flux2klein.md`
## Best first test
- Validate the maintained `MiniMax H3` best-current R2V master on the `3070` with the new prompt hierarchy, then compare it against the same-day `javawock7618` `INT8 R2V` donor if time allows.
## What still needs proof
- Whether the same-day `MiniMax H3` donor is actually practical on Chris's box.
- Whether `Z-Image` edit workflows meaningfully beat the current FLUX edit baseline.
- Whether `LTX-2.5` reference control is strong enough to justify a future promoted master.
+11 -1
View File
@@ -6,19 +6,29 @@
## What to look for ## What to look for
- strong `text-to-image` workflows - strong official `text-to-image` workflows
- reference and edit workflows - reference and edit workflows
- outpaint / inpaint workflows - outpaint / inpaint workflows
- high-quality upscaling or restoration-adjacent workflows - high-quality upscaling or restoration-adjacent workflows
- any workflow that clearly beats a comparable `FLUX` path in practical image quality or simplicity - any workflow that clearly beats a comparable `FLUX` path in practical image quality or simplicity
## Strong current source workflows
- `models/zimage/z-image-turbo-official-example/`
- `models/zimage/z-image-turbo-inpainting-community/`
- `models/zimage/z-image-turbo-controlnet-union-community/`
- `models/zimage/qujincheng-z-image-lora-facetailer/` for face-detail follow-up, not as a core generator
## Current heuristics ## Current heuristics
- Prefer real workflow assets over showcase pages. - Prefer real workflow assets over showcase pages.
- Favor workflows with clear node requirements and portable imports. - Favor workflows with clear node requirements and portable imports.
- Treat `Z-Image` as especially relevant for image-generation and image-edit categories, not video categories. - Treat `Z-Image` as especially relevant for image-generation and image-edit categories, not video categories.
- Keep the official example as the clean text-to-image baseline, then compare the community inpaint and controlnet-union graphs against it for real edit gains.
- Treat facetailer-style graphs as post-pass helpers unless they prove they can stand alone.
## What still needs proof ## What still needs proof
- which `Z-Image` workflows are genuinely stronger than the best current `FLUX` image-generation paths - which `Z-Image` workflows are genuinely stronger than the best current `FLUX` image-generation paths
- whether `Z-Image` should become a category-master candidate for `text-to-image` or `image-edit` - whether `Z-Image` should become a category-master candidate for `text-to-image` or `image-edit`
- whether the inpaint or union-style community graph is the better maintained edit baseline on Chris's machine