diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/README.md b/optimized/T2I/flux/README.md index 16fbf6b..c21febb 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/README.md +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/README.md @@ -25,7 +25,7 @@ The positive prompt is the shared T2I comparison prompt in [`../prompt.txt`](../ ## Planned optimization matrix -All rows are intentionally **Untested**. Keep the prompt, seed, and resolution from [`../variables.json`](../variables.json) fixed. Flux2Scheduler does not expose a selectable scheduler, so that value remains fixed. +All rows have now been tested. Keep the prompt, seed, and resolution from [`../variables.json`](../variables.json) fixed. Flux2Scheduler does not expose a selectable scheduler, so that value remains fixed. | ID | CFG | Steps | Sampler | Scheduler | Runtime (s) | Tested? | Current Best | |---|---:|---:|---|---|---:|---|---| diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-01.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-01.json index 54a3aa9..b9be656 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-01.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-01.json @@ -15,7 +15,8 @@ "output_file": "F-T2I-01.png", "status": "completed", "output_sha256": "0763ecc78284c6ec39bb1461af0ae649be90882ddb2594099150ed085680555c", - "verdict": "Strong vertical baseline: realistic stadium scene, subject detail, and readable composition; foreground foot is soft but acceptable.", - "better_than_current_best": true, - "current_best": true + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid and realistic, but softer and less cleanly composed than F-T2I-03; not promoted.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-02.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-02.json index 494c041..bdb267a 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-02.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-02.json @@ -14,6 +14,7 @@ "output_file": "F-T2I-02.png", "status": "completed", "output_sha256": "6852e2c0484996af5ff2c65564160f711a8be4a559d88cd121ab30decb49090d", + "tested": true, "verdict": "Tested; slightly weaker than F-T2I-03 and not promoted.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-03.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-03.json index e48bfa1..65f0d68 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-03.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-03.json @@ -14,7 +14,8 @@ "output_file": "F-T2I-03.png", "status": "completed", "output_sha256": "bd2f73b34008fa254bceebdbfd9fd6e03ac40a6c452ea7420c8dba72b0f94f66", - "verdict": "Better than the previous Flux best: strong portrait realism, cleaner scoreboard composition, and faster runtime.", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Current best: strongest portrait realism, cleanest scoreboard composition, stable anatomy, and fast runtime.", "better_than_current_best": true, "current_best": true } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-04.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-04.json index f3103ad..250d228 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-04.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-04.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "output_sha256": "203e3a3bf548adfb8bcd90efcc5d4f3816ebf47da7c4d14405975f2f26eb3e09", "status": "completed", "comfy_prompt_id": "81901e9a-32b9-4a38-ac3d-6c8cc24510c1", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-04_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-04_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid output with good realism and prompt adherence, but F-T2I-03 has cleaner portrait and scoreboard composition.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-05.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-05.json index 2d0de92..956f582 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-05.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-05.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 10.066, "output_file": "F-T2I-05.png", "output_sha256": "dced094de37449db9ccfdee2ea4b6ba70bd60be507721a8bbc043e255c475361", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-05_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-05_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid and visually competitive, but the unusually short warm/cache runtime is not representative and image quality does not exceed F-T2I-03.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-06.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-06.json index 836632d..ef21e83 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-06.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-06.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 156.231, "output_file": "F-T2I-06.png", "output_sha256": "22f638525a04b00af3a2daecfc2f8a67136c1a254c3404e6fac11b00b1e752a4", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-06_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-06_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid, but weaker overall realism/composition and less stable fine detail than F-T2I-03.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-07.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-07.json index 00574c8..9510e32 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-07.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-07.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 180.266, "output_file": "F-T2I-07.png", "output_sha256": "2aeb35281a7ee783b26a15e599143fb6c10475662075dc14279ba30ffa481ee6", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-07_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-07_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid, with acceptable anatomy and prompt adherence, but no improvement over F-T2I-03 in realism or composition.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-08.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-08.json index 9d2025a..998d7b3 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-08.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-08.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 172.25, "output_file": "F-T2I-08.png", "output_sha256": "bca5836b70684f3c52978bd114d06074249d22a3a67c4d3b4ff55951f98132c8", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-08_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-08_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid, but less controlled photographic rendering and detail than the F-T2I-03 baseline.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-09.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-09.json index 110e10a..b94a616 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-09.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-09.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 220.307, "output_file": "F-T2I-09.png", "output_sha256": "cb671fbb5518ccfd4928b1a85b70ecb7be6516406ae04bb8d0b1329becc831b7", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-09_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-09_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid, but inferior to F-T2I-03 in overall composition, anatomy stability, and photographic finish.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-10.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-10.json index 18200d9..706088c 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-10.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-10.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 224.319, "output_file": "F-T2I-10.png", "output_sha256": "a63f8ef40bff84ac18631ab561abc1434a38504126c25605f5765aa067260fcb", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-10_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-10_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid, but no improvement over F-T2I-03 in realism, composition, or artifact control.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-11.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-11.json index 97a2f41..6e453fc 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-11.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-11.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 180.258, "output_file": "F-T2I-11.png", "output_sha256": "7d36fadee6be1589f919aebd89e6d9609d6e27fd76242df8733e62d75ae443c0", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-11_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-11_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid, but less convincing and less compositionally clean than F-T2I-03.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-12.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-12.json index 1cdecbd..202254a 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-12.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-12.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 124.211, "output_file": "F-T2I-12.png", "output_sha256": "b7468a7e1270090a46d7f4995035b82512b5c7779fe801d23981285978e2be85", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-12_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-12_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Rejected as corrupted/highly oversaturated; tested but invalid and not eligible for Current Best.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-13.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-13.json index c108573..82811ff 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-13.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-13.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 122.194, "output_file": "F-T2I-13.png", "output_sha256": "0c7bd34d5ec011af7a39b614afd46e31dad76d8505e0af8404265c54c50e49cf", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-13_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-13_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid, but reduced-step output is less detailed and less realistic than F-T2I-03.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-14.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-14.json index 0a90318..083b2de 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-14.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-14.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 178.417, "output_file": "F-T2I-14.png", "output_sha256": "f3f709443f962046e8c2296a1e9d35f44dfbaafdcaf6d65d203f87553ca41f2f", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-14_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-14_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid, but the five-step result does not match F-T2I-03's realism and fine-detail balance.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-15.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-15.json index d8919ae..6b98211 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-15.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-15.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 226.32, "output_file": "F-T2I-15.png", "output_sha256": "7c07ddbabe38a67d3c37e38fa1e5ced87e8cd2a3b470740c44a613597f47bee6", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-15_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-15_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid and among the closest alternatives, but F-T2I-03 remains cleaner and more balanced overall.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-16.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-16.json index a407ed5..dcff8ca 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-16.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-16.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 282.393, "output_file": "F-T2I-16.png", "output_sha256": "ecd3277647cc9e9bffe762575301022956dcb6ed551a374790cf25b1512d5cc0", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-16_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-16_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid, but extra steps do not improve realism or composition over F-T2I-03.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-17.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-17.json index 3513314..2f61087 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-17.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-17.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 70.355, "output_file": "F-T2I-17.png", "output_sha256": "3d5d10f5e606a61778dcbe0b6462db39e74fb6d0289713e01e6cc1a579e679fd", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-17_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-17_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid, but reduced-step ancestral sampling is less refined than F-T2I-03.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-18.json b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-18.json index 3bb28ed..8e15f79 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-18.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/flux/results/F-T2I-18.json @@ -22,5 +22,9 @@ "runtime_seconds": 148.229, "output_file": "F-T2I-18.png", "output_sha256": "f6f84db86dd1508f2357254be983959227fb0a91013018289e04c5a9f489389d", - "source_filename": "F-T2I-18_00001_.png" + "source_filename": "F-T2I-18_00001_.png", + "tested": true, + "verdict": "Valid, but inferior to F-T2I-03 in photographic realism, detail, and composition.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false }