From 7a09bfd29f3586c8ede8b46bbb36518faf2b4c6f Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Morpheus Date: Fri, 25 Sep 2026 19:45:06 +0000 Subject: [PATCH] Evaluate remaining Qwen T2I tests --- optimized/T2I/README.md | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/README.md | 12 ++++++++---- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-01.json | 6 +++--- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-03.json | 11 +++++++---- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-04.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-05.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-06.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-07.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-08.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-09.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-10.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-11.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-12.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-13.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-14.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-15.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-16.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-17.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-18.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-19.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-20.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-21.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-22.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-23.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-24.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-25.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-26.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-27.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-28.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-29.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-35.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-39.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-40.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-41.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-42.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-43.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-44.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-45.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-46.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-47.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-48.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-49.json | 6 +++--- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-50.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-51.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-52.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-53.json | 2 +- optimized/T2I/qwen/ui-workflow.json | 4 ++-- optimized/T2I/qwen/workflow.json | 4 ++-- 48 files changed, 67 insertions(+), 60 deletions(-) diff --git a/optimized/T2I/README.md b/optimized/T2I/README.md index 1f2d235..0aec97a 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/README.md +++ b/optimized/T2I/README.md @@ -13,6 +13,6 @@ This summary is maintained across the model-specific test plans. A result is onl | Model | Best so far | Runtime | Generated image | Status | |---|---|---:|---|---| | Flux.2 Klein | F-T2I-03 | 220.3 s | [F-T2I-03.png](flux/results/F-T2I-03.png) | Current best; 1080×1920 target | -| Qwen Image 2.1 | Q-T2I-35 | 109.7 s | [Q-T2I-35.png](qwen/results/Q-T2I-35.png) | Current best; direct 1088×1920 latent | +| Qwen Image 2.1 | Q-T2I-49 | 110.6 s | [Q-T2I-49.png](qwen/results/Q-T2I-49.png) | Current best; direct 1088×1920 latent; euler_cfg_pp, beta, 25 steps, CFG 2.5 | Store each T2I test under the selected model's `results/.png` and `results/.json` using the table ID as the label. diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/README.md b/optimized/T2I/qwen/README.md index ac83ef7..e02ed36 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/README.md +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/README.md @@ -10,9 +10,9 @@ Qwen Image 2.1 text-to-image workflow using the best tested sampler, scheduler, - Internal generation: 1088×1920 portrait latent (generated directly at target resolution) - Final output: 1088×1920, 9:16, decoded directly from the target-resolution latent - Sampler: euler_cfg_pp -- Scheduler: simple +- Scheduler: beta - Steps: 25 -- CFG: 1.4 +- CFG: 2.5 - Seed: 20260920 - Runtime: recorded per test in the matrix; previous 1024-square baseline invalidated by this workflow update @@ -58,7 +58,7 @@ Keep the prompt, seed, and resolution from [`../variables.json`](../variables.js | Q-T2I-32 | 1.1 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | simple | 109.4 | Yes | No | | Q-T2I-33 | 1.2 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | simple | 109.3 | Yes | No | | Q-T2I-34 | 1.3 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | simple | 110.0 | Yes | No | -| Q-T2I-35 | 1.4 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | simple | 109.7 | Yes | Yes | +| Q-T2I-35 | 1.4 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | simple | 109.7 | Yes | No | | Q-T2I-36 | 1.5 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | simple | 109.9 | Yes | No | | Q-T2I-37 | 1.6 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | simple | 110.0 | Yes | No | | Q-T2I-38 | 1.8 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | simple | — | Yes | No | @@ -72,7 +72,7 @@ Keep the prompt, seed, and resolution from [`../variables.json`](../variables.js | Q-T2I-46 | 2.5 | 25 | res_multistep_cfg_pp | simple | 110.0 | Yes | No | | Q-T2I-47 | 2.5 | 25 | res_multistep_ancestral | simple | 111.4 | Yes | No | | Q-T2I-48 | 2.5 | 25 | res_multistep_ancestral_cfg_pp | simple | 111.1 | Yes | No | -| Q-T2I-49 | 2.5 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | beta | 110.6 | Yes | No | +| Q-T2I-49 | 2.5 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | beta | 110.6 | Yes | Yes | | Q-T2I-50 | 2.5 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | sgm_uniform | 109.8 | Yes | No | | Q-T2I-51 | 2.5 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | karras | 110.9 | Yes | No | | Q-T2I-52 | 2.5 | 25 | euler_cfg_pp | exponential | 113.2 | Yes | No | @@ -81,3 +81,7 @@ Keep the prompt, seed, and resolution from [`../variables.json`](../variables.js Files: - workflow.json — API format - ui-workflow.json — ComfyUI web UI format + +Visual evaluation notes: +- Current best: Q-T2I-49. +- Rejected as corrupted: Q-T2I-17, Q-T2I-18, Q-T2I-19, Q-T2I-22, Q-T2I-23, Q-T2I-46, Q-T2I-47, Q-T2I-48, Q-T2I-51, and Q-T2I-52. diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-01.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-01.json index 3bbba4d..edab7a8 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-01.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-01.json @@ -14,7 +14,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 315.5, "output_file": "Q-T2I-01.png", "output_sha256": "80b6640b1950e896cd4fec5ec9b400fafe7b8719135cd87bcd0d4021a10cc54d", - "verdict": "Strong portrait baseline: excellent face and clothing detail; foreground legs and foot are softer and less anatomically clean than Flux.", - "better_than_current_best": true, - "current_best": true + "verdict": "Tested; superseded by Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-03.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-03.json index 4affe26..455f5ab 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-03.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-03.json @@ -5,7 +5,10 @@ "prompt_sha256": "5802909ebe894260b70a3977430e08aaa95732e0559749d8cb42e2f5ecf3ab6f", "seed": 20260920, "input_images": [], - "resolution": [1088, 1920], + "resolution": [ + 1088, + 1920 + ], "cfg": 1.1, "steps": 12, "sampler": "euler_cfg_pp", @@ -13,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 94.7, "output_file": "Q-T2I-03.png", "output_sha256": "6c2f71bcf98f4163c4c8b33dea1e42d4281a7bde961468a3525903035d030469", - "verdict": "Better than the previous Qwen best: strong portrait detail and substantially faster cached runtime.", - "better_than_current_best": true, - "current_best": true + "verdict": "Tested; superseded by Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", + "better_than_current_best": false, + "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-04.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-04.json index 264b2b5..3d9c6c7 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-04.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-04.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 52.97, "output_file": "Q-T2I-04.png", "output_sha256": "e907e2827e05ed457dc3f89b8237d2099db16e63101d3fef6703f9c0acb1b464", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-05.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-05.json index 602e4cd..cff5339 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-05.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-05.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 53.14, "output_file": "Q-T2I-05.png", "output_sha256": "b2b97ddecba4fc312fba6079d94b15abc254eba714b3cdce8a35acc439fe00f1", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-06.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-06.json index 7b52470..6de440c 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-06.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-06.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 56.09, "output_file": "Q-T2I-06.png", "output_sha256": "401d9fcc3da539f591b3fcf9d9c9bac278f53cda7947c987ec0373a69ec2a283", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-07.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-07.json index be8557b..8cc1eb4 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-07.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-07.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 56.36, "output_file": "Q-T2I-07.png", "output_sha256": "f8591a3951c81aa18f2ef34537bcee43f70d4b84c8a1fa0708b458ce05b95219", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-08.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-08.json index 6097c11..36758f6 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-08.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-08.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 55.18, "output_file": "Q-T2I-08.png", "output_sha256": "2f7ed082246e34bd29116ca2d2d248309c5fcfb41204dc8e5a5dc6c20c458df3", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-09.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-09.json index ceec91e..4dbad39 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-09.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-09.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 53.36, "output_file": "Q-T2I-09.png", "output_sha256": "5728257d3f53c814aa300175d0a3f79d886872ed19f222dd14f62e6a0ad64f90", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-10.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-10.json index 84a3516..07aa063 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-10.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-10.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 53.61, "output_file": "Q-T2I-10.png", "output_sha256": "012badd133d8aa91c863dd57501a7694689c210daad14ece374a472cc276ade4", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-11.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-11.json index 8d30ec7..b72e256 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-11.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-11.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 55.94, "output_file": "Q-T2I-11.png", "output_sha256": "857e82f26fe457930e60813a92e6a19b2ac269116802eefe9f6de328f5ff3124", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-12.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-12.json index b0ff805..c5dc16b 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-12.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-12.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 54.71, "output_file": "Q-T2I-12.png", "output_sha256": "cf139aa97562d189d99c4aa55211209fbc80f6f7c9d65703611036b8044b7c31", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-13.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-13.json index 2518dca..c32859d 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-13.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-13.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 54.28, "output_file": "Q-T2I-13.png", "output_sha256": "9692fa6755f08ddc2ba970207aef2a7b27cfa42f4a6b7167b3a2cdcf5e7b74c9", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-14.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-14.json index b9e51da..94b9f5b 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-14.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-14.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 54.44, "output_file": "Q-T2I-14.png", "output_sha256": "4ee98fe7c78f1b0bcd14de5e7263545f8ee80f0b703776109211ab72cc10cbae", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-15.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-15.json index 713ad14..b0794ff 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-15.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-15.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 54.17, "output_file": "Q-T2I-15.png", "output_sha256": "9888e64f3274c03738b002ddad29421e15e630d694a6d2f9d0a6ab033b4b5481", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-16.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-16.json index 6b062e1..14cd896 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-16.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-16.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 57.47, "output_file": "Q-T2I-16.png", "output_sha256": "6aa46d213da3e2f13fe6c859b595b6244a056a1d7999ca111e428815e56bb641", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-17.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-17.json index 8bd1b65..f15706a 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-17.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-17.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 54.27, "output_file": "Q-T2I-17.png", "output_sha256": "2b60f2c04b8779fcd4d8619bc373b0504cf0719aa128f99222effe6ba4629ed4", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Invalid/corrupted output during visual evaluation.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-18.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-18.json index 9317128..859b577 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-18.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-18.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 56.83, "output_file": "Q-T2I-18.png", "output_sha256": "59c9ad8aaa23ec28af1d3e1bed004ac7c8681bf61072e66a1b7e3628e4ec3a96", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Invalid/corrupted output during visual evaluation.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-19.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-19.json index 301b74a..6ab2038 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-19.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-19.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 57.18, "output_file": "Q-T2I-19.png", "output_sha256": "afb4fcba90f50a5dfdd2f68e932faadc905bd9f48df2b74dff905c0fa28bde96", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Invalid/corrupted output during visual evaluation.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-20.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-20.json index 159e95a..b372dc8 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-20.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-20.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 54.06, "output_file": "Q-T2I-20.png", "output_sha256": "7f583297f996f198db0d1e58f476b22732b55cba3acad6568ff00c215d654759", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-21.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-21.json index d340364..08cb189 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-21.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-21.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 54.49, "output_file": "Q-T2I-21.png", "output_sha256": "ab187f34571c786a435c8aedbc3ebe3928c9ff775c99b9754952cdce778ce42d", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-22.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-22.json index 629d316..8e01e37 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-22.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-22.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 55.33, "output_file": "Q-T2I-22.png", "output_sha256": "6c418e46b8c7b88457e510bbf911c469f64e046e6a2636842a09d33decbc5a39", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Invalid/corrupted output during visual evaluation.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-23.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-23.json index b5f27a5..689740a 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-23.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-23.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 54.12, "output_file": "Q-T2I-23.png", "output_sha256": "ad8f3ffa335c90b41a146f506c754bb770545524b2f015932854acf142fb88a6", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Invalid/corrupted output during visual evaluation.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-24.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-24.json index 76a6436..a1e7585 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-24.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-24.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 54.42, "output_file": "Q-T2I-24.png", "output_sha256": "2255a7f15ba370bf81652586892c3bc8c7aaf61dd99d738462aac09c1c981933", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-25.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-25.json index 81adaf9..01bc5e3 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-25.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-25.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 89.65, "output_file": "Q-T2I-25.png", "output_sha256": "0d4fa926c711ed3739b328cd4fea762a079af19d3e9543821c10d113385dc5d0", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-26.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-26.json index ac415a9..d9eb8be 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-26.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-26.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 131.56, "output_file": "Q-T2I-26.png", "output_sha256": "9ebc0cd04fbb9874153555c6361c9f2c1a27ff3396250840c213ff900550dfbb", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-27.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-27.json index 9ad8e72..bdc74ad 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-27.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-27.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 175.38, "output_file": "Q-T2I-27.png", "output_sha256": "38b50194d1acd920ff4a6e10ec01e9401123857d9022425229a89ec127f7db15", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-28.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-28.json index ddcfc94..a082e23 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-28.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-28.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 89.81, "output_file": "Q-T2I-28.png", "output_sha256": "f7da6bb88c1d356bf2017e8a346d56ffaa235b5e9d952386dae3f770e77a81f6", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-29.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-29.json index e05192b..a06536d 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-29.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-29.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 88.38, "output_file": "Q-T2I-29.png", "output_sha256": "30d8b1bfe09b1f1dee8ae6092d877e9724bb2712b11b044a1777f23fc4f17709", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-35.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-35.json index b77b8b5..f592047 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-35.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-35.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 109.7, "output_file": "Q-T2I-35.png", "output_sha256": "047f69701a73ad80668ca8c21a0c979a6b66a229e959a063cbba50d556668f19", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; superseded by Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-39.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-39.json index 955d619..126b8e4 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-39.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-39.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 111.37, "output_file": "Q-T2I-39.png", "output_sha256": "6a71f6407d34bae9a6759a132370fba4af5139c4bec8ae5377cdab4d9a33533c", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-40.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-40.json index fc8cd5b..574aa9b 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-40.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-40.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 109.87, "output_file": "Q-T2I-40.png", "output_sha256": "54c493f893383da2b40ef62ce1cfb81da6d5033f6617acde89c509600ff47ec0", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-41.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-41.json index 7685ee9..41034f6 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-41.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-41.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 110.54, "output_file": "Q-T2I-41.png", "output_sha256": "e5dca2622953a8f49fa67efcdbde32becc50ccfe14b765bce23c07ecf53c7408", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-42.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-42.json index adcc586..fd49b9a 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-42.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-42.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 110.65, "output_file": "Q-T2I-42.png", "output_sha256": "70765556f4b221fc29338bd78d8dbe6ad657b44cdb8e959e29591f9731ffeb00", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-43.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-43.json index 1338e4e..273dd8b 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-43.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-43.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 113.3, "output_file": "Q-T2I-43.png", "output_sha256": "e55b614a34eb08263349dea407f6659e77dc0e00dc1efe6e1d57af64de519412", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-44.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-44.json index f9211d4..58689ce 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-44.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-44.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 110.1, "output_file": "Q-T2I-44.png", "output_sha256": "3ec6cab2fc067699ad826c2330ef006b39121c871e3fd181777f6ad4f410d64e", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-45.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-45.json index a758582..3ab314c 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-45.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-45.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 109.76, "output_file": "Q-T2I-45.png", "output_sha256": "00237d57afaa089af367863d09861eeede39ef7e17c4cdba3ad83d1fb4c1656a", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-46.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-46.json index f83ff35..029364b 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-46.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-46.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 110.05, "output_file": "Q-T2I-46.png", "output_sha256": "ff54000bf8914b30c1f6bea60e0800211c1aeba206d4945c5db609f65445dde6", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Invalid/corrupted output during visual evaluation.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-47.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-47.json index ab10b4d..3480c11 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-47.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-47.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 111.37, "output_file": "Q-T2I-47.png", "output_sha256": "3beba76aa75c56bdc2c3c4c8bcb6d99ae470cc88416b773f77c3dcc9d0792d4d", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Invalid/corrupted output during visual evaluation.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-48.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-48.json index ef93839..a422054 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-48.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-48.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 111.07, "output_file": "Q-T2I-48.png", "output_sha256": "663cbe59c66527580e4342262eb9b2b7862a1915b4b5d0fb920cc38b773d6b26", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Invalid/corrupted output during visual evaluation.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-49.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-49.json index b9dc4bc..e835221 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-49.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-49.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 110.6, "output_file": "Q-T2I-49.png", "output_sha256": "cf536e0c0c052b874807252525214ce686b2a07aa1226719b79c73c6163081c1", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", - "better_than_current_best": false, - "current_best": false + "verdict": "Better than the previous Qwen best after full-batch visual comparison: strongest balance of photographic detail, lighting, stadium context, subject clarity, and valid anatomy.", + "better_than_current_best": true, + "current_best": true } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-50.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-50.json index 1dbd99e..f5228a6 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-50.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-50.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 109.84, "output_file": "Q-T2I-50.png", "output_sha256": "4acfa5c6a5ecd7bbbbaa9729c04b472686b6709463740e503509b270e43b46b9", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-51.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-51.json index be216c1..6f422a2 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-51.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-51.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 110.86, "output_file": "Q-T2I-51.png", "output_sha256": "cddabefc1ca6d342659dd9c165178453b293e6ab06cd942b41a733d4e8569454", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Invalid/corrupted output during visual evaluation.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-52.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-52.json index a459a58..73f22c6 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-52.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-52.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 113.24, "output_file": "Q-T2I-52.png", "output_sha256": "4aabf44bdd4e5816a5e55b15b3252d10cd86b93364e7d42855cf52ccfff86841", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Invalid/corrupted output during visual evaluation.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-53.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-53.json index e4156df..6dbc708 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-53.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/results/Q-T2I-53.json @@ -16,7 +16,7 @@ "runtime_seconds": 114.35, "output_file": "Q-T2I-53.png", "output_sha256": "d0c7e5fdf50925677a2d190fc6d41ea62f72cdbbde72af8418980faa6415d58b", - "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-03 after visual comparison.", + "verdict": "Tested; not promoted over Q-T2I-49 after visual comparison.", "better_than_current_best": false, "current_best": false } diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/ui-workflow.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/ui-workflow.json index 99fd380..d1bb0fc 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/ui-workflow.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/ui-workflow.json @@ -256,7 +256,7 @@ "Node name for S&R": "BasicScheduler" }, "widgets_values": [ - "simple", + "beta", 25, 1 ] @@ -336,7 +336,7 @@ "Node name for S&R": "CFGGuider" }, "widgets_values": [ - 1.4 + 2.5 ] }, { diff --git a/optimized/T2I/qwen/workflow.json b/optimized/T2I/qwen/workflow.json index 16d872a..969acb0 100644 --- a/optimized/T2I/qwen/workflow.json +++ b/optimized/T2I/qwen/workflow.json @@ -60,7 +60,7 @@ "4", 0 ], - "scheduler": "simple", + "scheduler": "beta", "steps": 25, "denoise": 1 } @@ -86,7 +86,7 @@ "5", 1 ], - "cfg": 1.4 + "cfg": 2.5 } }, "10": {