# Ideogram 4 — author-informed T2I tests This section follows the model card and author workflow: structured Ideogram 4 JSON captions, AuraFlow shift 5.25, StarSampler, and CFG 1.0. It is intended for controlled quality/time comparisons on the RTX 3070 server. ## Current direction - Main models: `ideogram4_int8_convrot.safetensors` and `Fal_Ideo_4_NSFW-int8_convrot.safetensors`, tested separately - Text encoder: `qwen3vl_8b_w4a8.safetensors`, type `ideogram4` - VAE: `flux2-vae.safetensors` - Prompt: Ideogram 4 structured JSON caption - Sampling: AuraFlow shift `5.25`; StarSampler, Euler, simple scheduler - Steps: author workflow 8; model-card reference 10 - CFG: `1.0` - Seed: 20261012 for the controlled baseline The Fal model is retained as a comparison only; it produced more stylised, noisier results. The hosted `IdeogramV4` API node was not used because this server is not authenticated for Comfy API partner nodes. ## Author-inspired comparison The model author publishes a workflow at [`Winnougan/Ideogram_Instant_NSFW`](https://huggingface.co/Winnougan/Ideogram_Instant_NSFW). It suggests a useful comparison branch rather than a replacement for the local baseline: - `Ideogram4PromptBuilderKJ` for structured prompt construction - `ModelSamplingAuraFlow` with `shift=5.25` - `StarSampler` with 8 steps, Euler, simple schedule, and CFG 1.0 - Fal Ideogram checkpoint with the local `flux2-vae.safetensors` The author's graph references `Boogu\\qwen3vl_8b_int8_convrot.safetensors`, which is not installed here, so the comparison uses the available `qwen3vl_8b_w4a8.safetensors`. Complete settings are recorded in [`author-inspired-settings.json`](author-inspired-settings.json). These settings remain comparison-only until a fixed prompt and seed are tested at 768×1024 and reviewed for typography, anatomy, texture, composition, and runtime. The model card also states that the fine-tune expects a structured JSON caption with `high_level_description` and `compositional_deconstruction` fields, and gives 10 steps with guidance scale 1.0 as its reference usage. The published ComfyUI graph uses 8 steps, so both settings are worth measuring separately. The card contains several unfinished placeholder sections, so its training and fine-tuning details should not be treated as verified claims. ## Initial observations - The 512×512 local smoke test completed successfully. - The 768×1024 standard Ideogram 4 run took about 6 minutes at 12 steps. - The 768×1024 Fal comparison took about 7 minutes at 12 steps. - The 8-step Fal run completed in about 5 minutes 18 seconds, but remained painterly and noisy. ## Current smoke tests The first smoke tests use the same 512×512 structured caption and seed before full-size tests are queued. Exact prompt IDs are recorded in `smoke-tests.json`. | ID | Model | Steps | Sampler | Scheduler | Shift | CFG | Status | |---|---|---:|---|---|---:|---:|---| | IDEO-SMOKE-FAL-10 | Fal Ideogram | 10 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Complete | | IDEO-SMOKE-LOCAL-08 | Local Ideogram | 8 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Complete | Smoke results: both completed without node errors. Fal took 45.483 seconds and was visually strong. Local took 29.268 seconds and was coherent but notably underexposed. The next full-size test should therefore start with Fal; local lighting/shift changes should be isolated rather than mixed into sampler tests. ## Revised quality/time matrix The previous free-form-prompt/dual-guider queue was stopped because its outputs did not meet the quality bar. Those IDs remain historical in `submissions.json`; they are not part of this new matrix. Keep the prompt and seed fixed for sampler tests. Keep all other settings fixed when changing one variable. A row is not promoted until detail, anatomy, composition, text fidelity, artefacts, and runtime are reviewed. | ID | Model | Resolution | Steps | Sampler | Scheduler | Shift | CFG | Purpose | Status | |---|---|---:|---:|---|---|---:|---:|---|---| | IDEO-AUTHOR-01 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Author sampling | Complete | | IDEO-AUTHOR-02 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Fal author sampling | Complete | | IDEO-CARD-10 | Fal | 768×1024 | 10 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Model-card step count | Complete | | IDEO-SAMPLER-01 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | res_multistep | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Sampler comparison | Complete | | IDEO-SAMPLER-02 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | euler_ancestral | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Sampler comparison | Complete | | IDEO-SCHED-01 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | Euler | beta | 5.25 | 1 | Scheduler comparison | Complete | | IDEO-SHIFT-01 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | Euler | simple | 3.0 | 1 | Shift comparison | Complete | | IDEO-SHIFT-02 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | Euler | simple | 7.0 | 1 | Shift comparison | Complete | | IDEO-STEPS-01 | Fal | 768×1024 | 6 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Speed lower bound | Complete | Quality ranking: `IDEO-CARD-10`, `IDEO-SCHED-01`, `IDEO-SHIFT-02`, `IDEO-AUTHOR-02`, `IDEO-AUTHOR-01`, `IDEO-SAMPLER-02`, `IDEO-STEPS-01`, `IDEO-SHIFT-01`, `IDEO-SAMPLER-01`. Several lower-ranked outputs contain a thin whisker/tendril artefact near the dragon's mouth. Results belong in `results/.png` with a matching JSON record containing the exact prompt, seed, resolution, settings, runtime, and visual verdict. ## Reuse Replace `STRUCTURED_JSON_CAPTION` in `workflow-author-inspired.json` with the caption from `smoke-tests.json` or a new test caption. Keep the seed and all other settings fixed while changing one matrix variable. ## Magazine-cover settings matrix The earlier magazine batches were discarded because their prompts and seeds varied between runs. The replacement matrix uses one fixed structured magazine caption, seed `20261234`, the Fal checkpoint, and the same VAE/text encoder. Only the listed technical variable changes per row. Prompt IDs and exact values are tracked in [`magazine-cover-matrix.json`](magazine-cover-matrix.json). | Group | Rows | Variable under test | |---|---|---| | Baseline/steps | 01–03 | 10, 8, and 6 steps | | Sampler | 04–05 | `res_multistep`, `euler_ancestral` | | Scheduler | 06–07 | `beta`, `sgm_uniform` | | CFG | 08–09 | 1.5 and 2.0 versus baseline 1.0 | | AuraFlow shift | 10–11 | 3.0 and 7.0 versus baseline 5.25 | | Resolution | 12 | 512×768 versus 768×1024 | Expanded rows 13–24 add `euler_cfg_pp`, `heun`, and `dpmpp_2m`; Karras and exponential schedulers; CFG 0.8, 1.2, and 3.0; AuraFlow shifts 4.0 and 6.0; 12 steps; and a 1024×1024 resolution test. They use the same fixed caption and seed as rows 01–12. ### Magazine matrix review All 24 rows completed. Runtime is wall-clock generation time on the RTX 3070; quality scores are a practical review of garment design, model/anatomy, composition, typography, and artefacts (10 = strongest overall result). | Rank | ID | Settings summary | Runtime | Quality | Review | |---:|---|---|---:|---:|---| | 1 | MAG-MATRIX-24 | 1024×1024, Euler/simple, 10 steps, CFG 1.0, shift 5.25 | 30.154s | 8.7 | Strongest garment variation and cleanest overall fashion image; square crop changes the composition. | | 2 | MAG-MATRIX-20 | 768×1024, Euler/simple, 10 steps, CFG 3.0 | 152.069s | 8.5 | Excellent asymmetric couture design and pose; slow, with weaker small cover text. | | 3 | MAG-MATRIX-09 | 768×1024, Euler/simple, 10 steps, CFG 2.0 | 149.682s | 8.4 | Strong garment structure and silhouette; slow and side text remains synthetic. | | 4 | MAG-MATRIX-12 | 512×768, Euler/simple, 10 steps, CFG 1.0 | 20.074s | 8.2 | Good alternate outfit and relatively clean cover hierarchy; lower resolution. | | 5 | MAG-MATRIX-05 | 768×1024, Euler-ancestral/simple, 10 steps, CFG 1.0 | 20.865s | 8.1 | Distinct tailored denim outfit and good anatomy; typography is less reliable. | | 6 | MAG-MATRIX-08 | 768×1024, Euler/simple, 10 steps, CFG 1.5 | 144.742s | 8.0 | Strong fitted denim design and pose; very slow, with noisy feature text. | The practical production candidate is **MAG-MATRIX-12** for speed/quality, with **MAG-MATRIX-24** as the best visual direction if square output is acceptable. MAG-MATRIX-16 and MAG-MATRIX-17 are rejected because of severe ghosting/blur. The high-CFG runs (08–09 and 20) produced more assertive garment structure but unexpectedly long runtimes on this server, so they are not default settings without a specific quality need. ### MAG-MATRIX-05 double-resolution rerun MAG-MATRIX-05 was rerun with only the resolution changed from 768×1024 to 1536×2048. The same prompt, seed `20261234`, Fal checkpoint, Euler ancestral sampler, simple scheduler, 10 steps, CFG 1.0, and AuraFlow shift 5.25 were retained. It completed successfully in **201.965s**. The result has stronger denim construction and detail, but the roughly 10× runtime makes it a quality mode rather than the default fast workflow. ### Research magazine batch The next production batch contains **150 covers** based on the 22 topic folders in the local Research repository. It uses the successful double- resolution baseline: Fal Ideogram checkpoint, 1536×2048, 10 steps, Euler ancestral, simple scheduler, CFG 1.0, AuraFlow shift 5.25, and the same VAE and text encoder. Seeds increment from `20261235` so the covers are distinct. Each prompt requires English-only, correctly spelled, legible typography and neat placement. Named people are treated as adult celebrity subjects in an editorial photoshoot; disputed material is framed as claims, reports, or documented history in the cover language. Submission IDs and topic mapping are recorded in `research-magazine-150-submissions.json`.