# I2I plus refiner tests This section contains image-to-image workflows where an edit model creates the first image and a separate refiner improves its surface quality, texture, and photorealism. Each run saves both the base-stage image and the refined image. The input image and canonical I2I prompt remain fixed when comparing refiner models. ## Current test The first test used Qwen NoctQ v4. The follow-up uses the proven Qwen Image 2.1 I2I stack and settings from `optimized/I2I/qwen/`, with the new reference image `refiner_reference.jpg`. The FLUX stage receives the Qwen pixels and has no text prompt, so it cannot replace the subject from text conditioning. | ID | Input | Prompt | Base stage | Refiner stage | Resolution | Generation time (s) | Status | Review | |---|---|---|---|---|---:|---:|---|---| | QRF-I2I-01 | `refiner_reference.jpg` | Canonical shared I2I prompt | NoctQ v4, 8 steps, CFG 1, Euler ancestral / beta | FLUX.3 Klein, 8 steps, guidance 1, Euler ancestral / simple, denoise 0.11 | 1088×1920 | 115.720 uncached; 0.274 cached | Completed | Base and refined outputs are nearly identical at denoise 0.11; [base PNG](results/QRF-I2I-01-base.png) vs [refined PNG](results/QRF-I2I-01.png) | | QRF-I2I-02 | `refiner_reference.jpg` | Canonical shared I2I prompt | Qwen Image 2.1, 50 steps, CFG 3.5, Euler CFG++ / beta | FLUX.3 Klein, 8 steps, guidance 1, Euler ancestral / simple, denoise 0.11 | Base 1080×1920; refined 1072×1920 | 145.129 | Completed | More realistic base; [base PNG](results/QRF-I2I-02-base.png) vs [refined PNG](results/QRF-I2I-02.png) | | QRF-I2I-03 | `refiner_reference.jpg` | Canonical shared I2I prompt | Qwen Image 2.1, 8 steps, CFG 1, Euler ancestral / beta | FLUX.3 Klein, 8 steps, guidance 1, Euler ancestral / simple, denoise 0.11 | Base 1080×1920; refined 1072×1920 | 60.252 | Completed | Realistic low-step base; white top/bottom bands; [base PNG](results/QRF-I2I-03-base.png) vs [refined PNG](results/QRF-I2I-03.png) | | ZRF-I2I-01 | `refiner_reference.jpg` | Canonical shared I2I prompt | Qwen Image 2.1, 8 steps, CFG 1, Euler ancestral / beta | ZImage Turbo, 5 steps, CFG 1, DPM++ 2M SDE / beta, denoise 0.33, shift 3 | Base/refined 1080×1920; refiner internal canvas 1088×1920 | 33.571 | Completed | Clean refiner output preserves the subject and clothing; [base PNG](results/ZRF-I2I-01-base.png) vs [refined PNG](results/ZRF-I2I-01.png) | | QRF-I2I-02-LF | `refiner_reference.jpg` | Canonical shared I2I prompt | Qwen Image 2.1, 8 steps, CFG 1, Euler ancestral / beta | FLUX.3 Klein, 8 steps, guidance 1, Euler ancestral / simple, denoise 0.11 | Base 1080×1920; refined 1072×1920 | 95.397 | Completed | Controlled like-for-like FLUX comparison against ZRF-I2I-01; [base PNG](results/QRF-I2I-02-LF-base.png) vs [refined PNG](results/QRF-I2I-02-LF.png) | ## Planned follow-ups - Additional refiner models only after the like-for-like comparison is reviewed. `QRF-I2I-02` remains the historical 50-step/CFG 3.5 run. `QRF-I2I-02-LF` is the controlled rerun with its Qwen base settings matched to `ZRF-I2I-01`. The FLUX workflow is `workflow.json`; the ZImage variant is `zimage-refiner-workflow.json`. Each resolved run records its prompt ID, model names, runtime, dimensions, hashes, and visual review in its matching metadata file under `results/`.