8.7 KiB
Ideogram 4 — author-informed T2I tests
This section follows the model card and author workflow: structured Ideogram 4 JSON captions, AuraFlow shift 5.25, StarSampler, and CFG 1.0. It is intended for controlled quality/time comparisons on the RTX 3070 server.
Current direction
- Main models:
ideogram4_int8_convrot.safetensorsandFal_Ideo_4_NSFW-int8_convrot.safetensors, tested separately - Text encoder:
qwen3vl_8b_w4a8.safetensors, typeideogram4 - VAE:
flux2-vae.safetensors - Prompt: Ideogram 4 structured JSON caption
- Sampling: AuraFlow shift
5.25; StarSampler, Euler, simple scheduler - Steps: author workflow 8; model-card reference 10
- CFG:
1.0 - Seed: 20261012 for the controlled baseline
The Fal model is retained as a comparison only; it produced more stylised,
noisier results. The hosted IdeogramV4 API node was not used because this
server is not authenticated for Comfy API partner nodes.
Author-inspired comparison
The model author publishes a workflow at
Winnougan/Ideogram_Instant_NSFW.
It suggests a useful comparison branch rather than a replacement for the
local baseline:
Ideogram4PromptBuilderKJfor structured prompt constructionModelSamplingAuraFlowwithshift=5.25StarSamplerwith 8 steps, Euler, simple schedule, and CFG 1.0- Fal Ideogram checkpoint with the local
flux2-vae.safetensors
The author's graph references Boogu\\qwen3vl_8b_int8_convrot.safetensors, which
is not installed here, so the comparison uses the available
qwen3vl_8b_w4a8.safetensors. Complete settings are recorded in
author-inspired-settings.json.
These settings remain comparison-only until a fixed prompt and seed are tested at 768×1024 and reviewed for typography, anatomy, texture, composition, and runtime.
The model card also states that the fine-tune expects a structured JSON caption
with high_level_description and compositional_deconstruction fields, and
gives 10 steps with guidance scale 1.0 as its reference usage. The published
ComfyUI graph uses 8 steps, so both settings are worth measuring separately.
The card contains several unfinished placeholder sections, so its training and
fine-tuning details should not be treated as verified claims.
Initial observations
- The 512×512 local smoke test completed successfully.
- The 768×1024 standard Ideogram 4 run took about 6 minutes at 12 steps.
- The 768×1024 Fal comparison took about 7 minutes at 12 steps.
- The 8-step Fal run completed in about 5 minutes 18 seconds, but remained painterly and noisy.
Current smoke tests
The first smoke tests use the same 512×512 structured caption and seed before
full-size tests are queued. Exact prompt IDs are recorded in smoke-tests.json.
| ID | Model | Steps | Sampler | Scheduler | Shift | CFG | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IDEO-SMOKE-FAL-10 | Fal Ideogram | 10 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Complete |
| IDEO-SMOKE-LOCAL-08 | Local Ideogram | 8 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Complete |
Smoke results: both completed without node errors. Fal took 45.483 seconds and was visually strong. Local took 29.268 seconds and was coherent but notably underexposed. The next full-size test should therefore start with Fal; local lighting/shift changes should be isolated rather than mixed into sampler tests.
Revised quality/time matrix
The previous free-form-prompt/dual-guider queue was stopped because its
outputs did not meet the quality bar. Those IDs remain historical in
submissions.json; they are not part of this new matrix.
Keep the prompt and seed fixed for sampler tests. Keep all other settings fixed when changing one variable. A row is not promoted until detail, anatomy, composition, text fidelity, artefacts, and runtime are reviewed.
| ID | Model | Resolution | Steps | Sampler | Scheduler | Shift | CFG | Purpose | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IDEO-AUTHOR-01 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Author sampling | Complete |
| IDEO-AUTHOR-02 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Fal author sampling | Complete |
| IDEO-CARD-10 | Fal | 768×1024 | 10 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Model-card step count | Complete |
| IDEO-SAMPLER-01 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | res_multistep | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Sampler comparison | Complete |
| IDEO-SAMPLER-02 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | euler_ancestral | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Sampler comparison | Complete |
| IDEO-SCHED-01 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | Euler | beta | 5.25 | 1 | Scheduler comparison | Complete |
| IDEO-SHIFT-01 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | Euler | simple | 3.0 | 1 | Shift comparison | Complete |
| IDEO-SHIFT-02 | Fal | 768×1024 | 8 | Euler | simple | 7.0 | 1 | Shift comparison | Complete |
| IDEO-STEPS-01 | Fal | 768×1024 | 6 | Euler | simple | 5.25 | 1 | Speed lower bound | Complete |
Quality ranking: IDEO-CARD-10, IDEO-SCHED-01, IDEO-SHIFT-02,
IDEO-AUTHOR-02, IDEO-AUTHOR-01, IDEO-SAMPLER-02, IDEO-STEPS-01,
IDEO-SHIFT-01, IDEO-SAMPLER-01. Several lower-ranked outputs contain a
thin whisker/tendril artefact near the dragon's mouth.
Results belong in results/<test-id>.png with a matching JSON record containing
the exact prompt, seed, resolution, settings, runtime, and visual verdict.
Reuse
Replace STRUCTURED_JSON_CAPTION in workflow-author-inspired.json with the
caption from smoke-tests.json or a new test caption. Keep the seed and all
other settings fixed while changing one matrix variable.
Magazine-cover settings matrix
The earlier magazine batches were discarded because their prompts and seeds
varied between runs. The replacement matrix uses one fixed structured magazine
caption, seed 20261234, the Fal checkpoint, and the same VAE/text encoder.
Only the listed technical variable changes per row. Prompt IDs and exact values
are tracked in magazine-cover-matrix.json.
| Group | Rows | Variable under test |
|---|---|---|
| Baseline/steps | 01–03 | 10, 8, and 6 steps |
| Sampler | 04–05 | res_multistep, euler_ancestral |
| Scheduler | 06–07 | beta, sgm_uniform |
| CFG | 08–09 | 1.5 and 2.0 versus baseline 1.0 |
| AuraFlow shift | 10–11 | 3.0 and 7.0 versus baseline 5.25 |
| Resolution | 12 | 512×768 versus 768×1024 |
Expanded rows 13–24 add euler_cfg_pp, heun, and dpmpp_2m; Karras and
exponential schedulers; CFG 0.8, 1.2, and 3.0; AuraFlow shifts 4.0 and 6.0;
12 steps; and a 1024×1024 resolution test. They use the same fixed caption
and seed as rows 01–12.
Magazine matrix review
All 24 rows completed. Runtime is wall-clock generation time on the RTX 3070; quality scores are a practical review of garment design, model/anatomy, composition, typography, and artefacts (10 = strongest overall result).
| Rank | ID | Settings summary | Runtime | Quality | Review |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | MAG-MATRIX-24 | 1024×1024, Euler/simple, 10 steps, CFG 1.0, shift 5.25 | 30.154s | 8.7 | Strongest garment variation and cleanest overall fashion image; square crop changes the composition. |
| 2 | MAG-MATRIX-20 | 768×1024, Euler/simple, 10 steps, CFG 3.0 | 152.069s | 8.5 | Excellent asymmetric couture design and pose; slow, with weaker small cover text. |
| 3 | MAG-MATRIX-09 | 768×1024, Euler/simple, 10 steps, CFG 2.0 | 149.682s | 8.4 | Strong garment structure and silhouette; slow and side text remains synthetic. |
| 4 | MAG-MATRIX-12 | 512×768, Euler/simple, 10 steps, CFG 1.0 | 20.074s | 8.2 | Good alternate outfit and relatively clean cover hierarchy; lower resolution. |
| 5 | MAG-MATRIX-05 | 768×1024, Euler-ancestral/simple, 10 steps, CFG 1.0 | 20.865s | 8.1 | Distinct tailored denim outfit and good anatomy; typography is less reliable. |
| 6 | MAG-MATRIX-08 | 768×1024, Euler/simple, 10 steps, CFG 1.5 | 144.742s | 8.0 | Strong fitted denim design and pose; very slow, with noisy feature text. |
The practical production candidate is MAG-MATRIX-12 for speed/quality, with MAG-MATRIX-24 as the best visual direction if square output is acceptable. MAG-MATRIX-16 and MAG-MATRIX-17 are rejected because of severe ghosting/blur. The high-CFG runs (08–09 and 20) produced more assertive garment structure but unexpectedly long runtimes on this server, so they are not default settings without a specific quality need.
MAG-MATRIX-05 double-resolution rerun
MAG-MATRIX-05 was rerun with only the resolution changed from 768×1024 to
1536×2048. The same prompt, seed 20261234, Fal checkpoint, Euler ancestral
sampler, simple scheduler, 10 steps, CFG 1.0, and AuraFlow shift 5.25 were
retained. It completed successfully in 201.965s. The result has stronger
denim construction and detail, but the roughly 10× runtime makes it a quality
mode rather than the default fast workflow.