Files

35 lines
3.2 KiB
Markdown
Raw Permalink Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
# I2I plus refiner tests
This section contains image-to-image workflows where an edit model creates the
first image and a separate refiner improves its surface quality, texture, and
photorealism. Each run saves both the base-stage image and the refined image.
The input image and canonical I2I prompt remain fixed when comparing refiner
models.
## Current test
The first test used Qwen NoctQ v4. The follow-up uses the proven Qwen Image 2.1
I2I stack and settings from `optimized/I2I/qwen/`, with the new reference image
`refiner_reference.jpg`. The FLUX stage receives the Qwen pixels and has no
text prompt, so it cannot replace the subject from text conditioning.
| ID | Input | Prompt | Base stage | Refiner stage | Resolution | Generation time (s) | Status | Review |
|---|---|---|---|---|---:|---:|---|---|
| QRF-I2I-01 | `refiner_reference.jpg` | Canonical shared I2I prompt | NoctQ v4, 8 steps, CFG 1, Euler ancestral / beta | FLUX.3 Klein, 8 steps, guidance 1, Euler ancestral / simple, denoise 0.11 | 1088×1920 | 115.720 uncached; 0.274 cached | Completed | Base and refined outputs are nearly identical at denoise 0.11; [base PNG](results/QRF-I2I-01-base.png) vs [refined PNG](results/QRF-I2I-01.png) |
| QRF-I2I-02 | `refiner_reference.jpg` | Canonical shared I2I prompt | Qwen Image 2.1, 50 steps, CFG 3.5, Euler CFG++ / beta | FLUX.3 Klein, 8 steps, guidance 1, Euler ancestral / simple, denoise 0.11 | Base 1080×1920; refined 1072×1920 | 145.129 | Completed | More realistic base; [base PNG](results/QRF-I2I-02-base.png) vs [refined PNG](results/QRF-I2I-02.png) |
| QRF-I2I-03 | `refiner_reference.jpg` | Canonical shared I2I prompt | Qwen Image 2.1, 8 steps, CFG 1, Euler ancestral / beta | FLUX.3 Klein, 8 steps, guidance 1, Euler ancestral / simple, denoise 0.11 | Base 1080×1920; refined 1072×1920 | 60.252 | Completed | Realistic low-step base; white top/bottom bands; [base PNG](results/QRF-I2I-03-base.png) vs [refined PNG](results/QRF-I2I-03.png) |
| ZRF-I2I-01 | `refiner_reference.jpg` | Canonical shared I2I prompt | Qwen Image 2.1, 8 steps, CFG 1, Euler ancestral / beta | ZImage Turbo, 5 steps, CFG 1, DPM++ 2M SDE / beta, denoise 0.33, shift 3 | Base/refined 1080×1920; refiner internal canvas 1088×1920 | 33.571 | Completed | Clean refiner output preserves the subject and clothing; [base PNG](results/ZRF-I2I-01-base.png) vs [refined PNG](results/ZRF-I2I-01.png) |
| QRF-I2I-02-LF | `refiner_reference.jpg` | Canonical shared I2I prompt | Qwen Image 2.1, 8 steps, CFG 1, Euler ancestral / beta | FLUX.3 Klein, 8 steps, guidance 1, Euler ancestral / simple, denoise 0.11 | Base 1080×1920; refined 1072×1920 | 95.397 | Completed | Controlled like-for-like FLUX comparison against ZRF-I2I-01; [base PNG](results/QRF-I2I-02-LF-base.png) vs [refined PNG](results/QRF-I2I-02-LF.png) |
## Planned follow-ups
- Additional refiner models only after the like-for-like comparison is reviewed.
`QRF-I2I-02` remains the historical 50-step/CFG 3.5 run. `QRF-I2I-02-LF`
is the controlled rerun with its Qwen base settings matched to `ZRF-I2I-01`.
The FLUX workflow is `workflow.json`; the ZImage variant is
`zimage-refiner-workflow.json`. Each resolved run records its prompt ID, model
names, runtime, dimensions, hashes, and visual review in its matching metadata
file under `results/`.